Newcomer

Share this post
Silicon Valley's Partisan Problem
www.newcomer.co

Silicon Valley's Partisan Problem

Too many people still think both parties look the same.

Eric Newcomer
Jan 4, 2021
Comment
Share

Politics is intruding on tech Twitter. So I have to agree with Marc Bodnick, we need to take a detour into tech’s political discussion — even though certain newsletter writers make their living obsessing over banalities like IPO pops.

Twitter avatar for @MarcBodnickMarc Bodnick @MarcBodnick
I'm looking forward to more tweets about IPO mispricing and crypto once this icky coup stuff goes away.

January 3rd 2021

5 Likes

I’m of two minds here. On the one hand, no one is paying me for my political hot takes. On the other hand, I do think we have a weird problem. Tech elites on Twitter want their political opinions to be taken seriously, but they express them in short bursts on a forum that doesn’t allow for thoughtful rebuttal. Many of them get by on having dedicated followings who are knee-jerk aligned with their political views. So just as they position themselves as free thinkers, they express their political views in a way that allows them to dismiss their critics and bask in the praise of their politically-aligned followers. Meanwhile, the actual political commentariat doesn’t really care what they have to say.

So, humble tech newsletter writers feel compelled to weigh in.

I’m going to assume you know the political context: a majority of House Republicans want to challenge the election result on Jan. 6, a group of about a dozen Senators now support that effort, and the lame duck President of the United States was recorded pressuring Georgia’s Secretary of State to “find” enough votes to flip the state’s presidential winner. Some Republicans like former Speaker of the House Paul Ryan, Senator Tom Cotton, and Senator Mitt Romney have come out and opposed efforts to challenge the election. Troublingly, all ten living former Secretaries of Defense decided that they needed to join together and write a warning against involving the military in election disputes. That’s weird.

Chris Sacca seemed to jumpstart a lot of the discussion on tech Twitter.

Twitter avatar for @saccaChris Sacca 🇺🇸 @sacca
There is only one (major) party of actual patriots. One party that puts country first. One party that fights for democracy and encourages voting for all. One party that honors the rule of law. Enough of this traitorous bullshit. It’s time for Democrats to take back the flag. 🇺🇸

January 3rd 2021

214 Retweets2,063 Likes
Twitter avatar for @saccaChris Sacca 🇺🇸 @sacca
I have zero tolerance for any “both sides” replies. The fake president is on tape undermining democracy with the full support of a shocking number of seditious Sens and Reps. We can disagree on taxes and Medicare. But you either believe in laws and the Constitution or you don’t.

January 3rd 2021

132 Retweets1,218 Likes

While many people agreed with him, there was also a strain of opposition. One product manager tweeted, “It's not true Chris. You're too deep in and letting yourself be fooled. One side is the slightly less worse option. That's the reality.”

Many in tech just keep quiet on Twitter when Republicans do crazy things. They prefer to complain about San Francisco socialists. I share Bodnick’s frustration with tech Twitter’s selective political tweeting.

Twitter avatar for @MarcBodnickMarc Bodnick @MarcBodnick
Maybe we can take a break from complaining about SF while the Republican Party is trying to execute a coup.

Brian Schatz @brianschatz

"I just want to find 11,780 votes" is cheating. We don't have to pretend it was "highly improper," or "extraordinary," or some other damned euphemistic nonsense.

January 3rd 2021

8 Retweets40 Likes

Cyan Banister, the angel investor and former Founders Fund partner, is braver than most. Banister offered several tweets objecting to Sacca.

Twitter avatar for @cyantistCyan @cyantist
I believe this kind of thing is divisive and the wrong direction to take. A true patriot would fly the flag especially in bad times. This is fickle faux patriotism. You fight for America always, not just when your team is in power.

Chris Sacca 🇺🇸 @sacca

There is only one (major) party of actual patriots. One party that puts country first. One party that fights for democracy and encourages voting for all. One party that honors the rule of law. Enough of this traitorous bullshit. It’s time for Democrats to take back the flag. 🇺🇸

January 3rd 2021

2 Retweets78 Likes
Twitter avatar for @cyantistCyan @cyantist
America isn’t a “Je suis Paris” campaign to make people feel good. Our rights are always worth fighting for and no party owns them. No party can stake claim to the flag. We are all under one great nation as Americans. Nobody gets to claim that half of a country is patriotic.

Chris Sacca 🇺🇸 @sacca

There is only one (major) party of actual patriots. One party that puts country first. One party that fights for democracy and encourages voting for all. One party that honors the rule of law. Enough of this traitorous bullshit. It’s time for Democrats to take back the flag. 🇺🇸

January 3rd 2021

2 Retweets53 Likes

I don’t think this was a fair reading of Sacca’s tweet. I took Sacca to be saying that Democrats should embrace patriotic branding — not patriotism itself — given they’re the ones protecting the Constitutional system of government right now. Presumably defending the Constitution is the the most patriotic thing you can do, so might as well get credit for it by putting an American flag logo next to your name on Twitter.

(I have to note that it’s classic rich person Democrat that Sacca is totally fine with people who don’t agree with him on taxes or Medicare. You know, the actual political substance of what Democrats are trying to achieve. But it’s a smart tactical concession on tech Twitter. Good to remind people you’re still willing to agree to disagree when it comes to their money, just not when it comes to democracy.)

But if you look at Banister’s replies, it’s clear that Banister thinks Democrats and Republicans are similarly culpable in creating our current political crisis. After all, they both complained about elections!

Twitter avatar for @cyantistCyan @cyantist
@knlae_ Both parties did it. Russian interference and now this. They are both to blame.

January 3rd 2021

I have to respond. The Democrats raised objections about Russian election interference with the support of the Trump Justice Department-appointed Special Counsel who found all sorts of troubling facts. Russians were charged with election interference. Trump encouraged the Russians to find Hillary Clinton’s emails on television. Don’t forget the President created a lot of the smoke himself by impeding the investigation. He fired his FBI director after demanding loyalty.

And remember that Clinton swiftly conceded the election. And the sitting Democratic president gracefully turned over power and offered counsel to the incoming administration. But yeah, they’re the same.

Twitter avatar for @cyantistCyan @cyantist
@knlae_ Do you think that the Democrats wouldn’t do the same thing if in the same position? Trust in our voting system is the issue here, not the parties. We’ve eroded trust. That trust must be regained. Do you think this helps people trust more or less?

January 3rd 2021

3 Likes

I mean this stuff is just infuriating. This is literally the second election that involves Donald Trump. Democrats handed over power the last time. This go around, elected Republicans have been fueling mistrust in the voting system and are now citing that widespread distrust as the reason that we need to investigate. It’s a wonderful circular argument.

Banister seems to want to shift the conversation to whether Republican voters are irredeemable. But the debate is over how to judge the Republican leaders they elected.

And ultimately it amounts to victim blaming. If an older sibling is picking on their younger sibling and a parent blames them both for fighting, that’s not fair. It undermines a parent’s credibility. You can’t apportion blame to everyone because that’s an easier world to accept. It just makes the situation worse.

They’re not just idle tweets. I looked up Banister’s political donations and they’re true to Banister’s professed beliefs. Banister has cut thousands of dollars to support Republican Senators Mike Lee, Ted Cruz, and Rand Paul, according to Open Secrets. But in 2019, Banister also donated thousands of dollars to support Pete Buttigieg, the plucky small-town mayor beloved by the tech set.

Buttigieg is spending all his energy trying to foil those Republican Senators. The split support is just mindboggling to me. I don’t want to spoil things by telling you who that charming mayor decided to go work for. The Democratic President-elect is actively trying to win two more Democratic Senate seats in Georgia to wrest power from Lee, Cruz, and Paul and their ilk.

I tweeted Sunday that Chamath Palihapitiya donated to Ted Cruz in 2011 and that Yelp CEO Jeremy Stoppelman donated money to Josh Hawley in 2018. Someone accused me of trying to censor political speech — and I could imagine the same critique being made against my harping on Banister’s tweets. I don’t see how I’m stopping them from doing anything. It’s probably good to have sufficiently strong convictions that you can weather criticism.

The real reason I’m spending so much time responding to Banister’s bothsidesing — is just that the fact patterns matter. Tech Twitter is full of intellectual posturing. Substack offers some space to see if things hold up in a few more than 280 characters.

Bobby Goodlatte took a stab at bothsidesing while holding on to his political convictions. (Goodlatte has earned a lot of credibility with me. He donated to his own father’s political opponent. That’s political courage.)

Twitter avatar for @rsgBobby Goodlatte 🇺🇸 @rsg
Tribalism is hard-wired into us. Reject it. It takes vigilance, but you can reject it. Call out members of your own tribe. This isn't the caveman era. You won't be exiled from some hunter-gatherer group. And those who value intellectual honesty will come to respect you for it.

January 4th 2021

6 Retweets51 Likes
Twitter avatar for @rsgBobby Goodlatte 🇺🇸 @rsg
For example: I'm a liberal. But I'm not afraid to call out excesses in the Democratic party. I think San Francisco is horribly run, for example. I also think that Republican mayor Suarez in Miami is doing a great job. While I think Trump is a stain on the nation. See? Not hard

January 4th 2021

5 Retweets47 Likes

Right. I mean I agree with Goodlatte. San Francisco is horribly run and Miami’s mayor is doing some interesting things. But many Silicon Valley Democrats would agree with those assertions. Despite the strawmen that are constructed on Twitter, most Americans like heterodoxy. These tweets make it seem like this is a bold position to stake out. I don’t think it is.

We just live in a reality where one national party is trying to destroy our democratic system and we’re supposed to act like both parties are the same. Democrats and other people living in this reality are going crazy because there’s a subsection of people who refuse to see what’s happening in front of them.

There are plenty of odd political alliances. Jason Calacanis is a hardcore Trump hater, but he’s also raising money to hire a journalist to investigate the ultra-liberal San Francisco District attorney. (Banister is donating to that campaign as well.)

Twitter avatar for @Jasonjason@calacanis.com @Jason
We are now at $35k in 24 hours — we can hit 75k if folks keep sharing this the citizens of #sanfrancisco & the #bayarea can hold @chesaboudin accountable with reporting — now we just need a journalist who wants to roll up their sleeves & hit the beat!
Report on Chesa Boudin’s Office & San SF Crime, organized by Jason McCabe CalacanisChesa Boudin’s approach to criminal justice is very unique. Th… Jason McCabe Calacanis needs your support for Report on Chesa Boudin’s Office & San SF Crimegf.me

January 4th 2021

15 Retweets46 Likes

I don’t have an issue with this particularly, so long as they hire a credible reporter and give them the independence to chase the facts. I believe that Calacanis will do that. It’s good that tech people are taking an interest in local government even if they do it in their own weird way!

Ultimately, I’m hopeful that there will be more common ground in 2021. It’s hard to feel like things can sink any lower. But to get there we need to live in a shared political reality. Democracy is good. Trump did his best to undermine it. Many of the Republican Party’s elected leaders remain happy to go along for the ride — even after their guy lost the election.

And I genuinely believe that it matters what Silicon Valley thinks. Tech is the most important global industry. Business leaders have tons of influence in government, while little time to spend thinking about it. I’d love to see Silicon Valley’s political views evolve.

But there’s also reason to worry that Silicon Valley won’t find a shared political reality. Yes, Silicon Valley is full of liberal Democrats who are inclined to agree with this column. But there’s also a strong strain of political nihilism in Silicon Valley. Tech wants to believe that it operates according to principles — unlike other industries like banking or big oil. But just like those industries, Silicon Valley sees the benefit of cozying up to the politically powerful, protecting its own class and business interests in the process.

If all politicians are the same, then you can support whoever you want — those politicians just happen to be acting in your economic interest. You’re not the one without principles, you tell yourself. It’s the politicians that don’t have scruples.

CommentComment
ShareShare

Create your profile

0 subscriptions will be displayed on your profile (edit)

Skip for now

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.

TopNewCommunity

No posts

Ready for more?

© 2022 Eric Newcomer
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Publish on Substack Get the app
Substack is the home for great writing